Almost there . . .
×
Site language modal icon
EN

📢 Every story has two sides. Don't skip the Nanny's Response.

Confinement Angels Fails to Deliver Quality Nannies, Causes Postpartum Distress

14
💤
Sleep on Duty
🤫
Poor Communication
👶
Neglecting Baby
😡
Disrespectful
🧼
Poor Hygiene
👥
Replacement Nanny
🤥
Dishonesty
Punctuality Issues
🤦
Messy Habits
Safety Negligence
🤷
Unauthorized Swap
📱
Phone Use
🫘
Bad Cooking
🚫
Ignoring Instructions
Agency, 2017
Singapore Singapore
Source: singaporemotherhood
Disastrous Confinement Experiences with PEM and Confinement Angels Nannies Leave Client Exhausted
🚮
🤥
🧔
👶
+11
Agency, 2024
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
妈妈吐槽PEM金牌月嫂:危险操作、卫生差、态度恶劣且不负责任
💥
🤥
🧔
💤
+6
Agency, 2024
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
Client Alleges Confinement Agency's Negligence After Horrific Experiences with Two Confinement Nannies
💥
😡
🧔
👶
+6
Agency, 2023
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
Mummy Reports Senior Confinement Nanny's Unhygienic Practices and Negligent Baby Care
👶
🧼
🤦
🚫
+3
Agency, 2023
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
PEM Agency's Nanny Chaos, Poor Service, and Payment Disputes Stress New Mom
👥
🧔
😡
🚫
+6
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
PEM Nanny's Bossy Attitude, Neglect, and Unsafe Baby Care
🚫
👶
🫘
+3
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
Confinement Nanny Mistreats Baby, Exhibits Negligence, Fired After Four Days
🚫
💤
🤫
👶
+1
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: hardwarezone
Confinement Nanny's Abusive Behavior, Neglect, and Disrespect Enrage Mother
🙅
👦
👶
🚫
+7
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
PEM Nanny #1734: Poor Hygiene, Negligent Care, Repetitive Cooking, Excessive Phone Use
🧔
🧼
👶
🚫
+4
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
PEM Confinement Nanny #1497: Negligent, Disobedient, and Unapologetic
📱
😡
💤
🚫
+5
Agency, 2022
Singapore Singapore
Source: facebook
Disclaimer

Summary of the Complaint

A client details a highly disappointing experience with Confinement Angels, engaging three nannies within 28 days, none meeting expectations. The complaint highlights issues with nanny health, dishonesty about experience, poor cooking, excessive phone use, and the agency's failure to provide promised quality, leading to immense stress during confinement.

Mummy's Key Complaints

bullet

First nanny fell sick after only five days, despite agency's health assurances.

bullet

First nanny did not perform full duties, leaving kitchen messy and causing baby's umbilical cord infection.

bullet

Second replacement nanny was a part-timer with no Singapore experience, not a 3-star nanny as paid for.

bullet

Second nanny overslept, snored loudly, responded slowly, and quit after two days.

bullet

Third nanny's skills were subpar, with poor cooking and unorganized meal planning.

bullet

Third nanny was caught using her phone excessively, including watching videos at midnight.

bullet

Third nanny used a washing machine for personal underwear and bra, despite hygiene rules.

bullet

Third nanny had communication issues, sometimes not hearing or understanding instructions.

bullet

Third nanny did not check ingredients in advance, leading to last-minute shortages.

bullet

Confinement Angels failed to provide promised high-quality, Thomson-trained nannies for replacements.

bullet

The agency's nannies did not allow luggage checks upon departure as per contract.

Under-qualification
Unprofessionalism

Full Complaint Details

We engaged Confinement Angels Nanny Services and have a confinement lady from 2017 Nov 05 to 2017 Dec 02 (28 days stay in). We were engaged 3 stars nannies services with additional $380 surcharge. They saying these nannies are superior in knowledge and service, with proven record by achieving 3 and above Excellent Customer Feedback.

My wife still doing confinement and changed 3 already. We decided to discontinue their services 1 week earlier. We were very disappointing about their nanny quality.

We were given this first confinement lady named Chris - YEONG CH** KI**. She is 52 years old. Before nanny arrival, we have requested the nanny profile.

1st Nanny Chris - YEONG CH** KI**.

My wife discharged from Thomson Medical Hospital on 05/Nov (Sunday) around 1:30pm and nanny arrived our house around 2:30pm, very on time. She is a very nice person to talk with, experienced and knowledgeable. Because of her good profile, we had gave her $58 red packet upon arrival. She went to Fair price with me at first day. After she came back from supermarket, she did not rest and straight away prepared dinner for my wife. We were very satisfied with the nanny performance after she worked for 3 days. We had told her that intended to extend her for 1 more month.

She was very particular about hygiene and professional.

-Prepared delicious and nutritious confinement foods, filling thermos with red dates tea.

-Guide us how to take care of baby, bathe, feed, burp, change diaper.

-When my baby did not fall sleep, she coax her to sleep and attention to her all the time. She would sleep only the baby does.

But the good times couldn't last forever. Day 5 (10/Nov), around 7:40pm nanny informed us that she feeling unwell and caught flu. She cannot handle baby and need to leave for few days to get some rest.

She informed us that need to leave immediately because do not want to spread virus. We were very shocked and panic during that night. Being first time mum and dad, we had no experience to handle baby and relied heavily on her. Also my wife C-sec for less than a week. So, that night nanny do nothing, whole night me and my wife take care of baby. She leave at next day. Confinement period only 28days, but she had worked only 5 days and need to take MC for few days, what a surprised.

As for replacement need to take 2-3 days, that mean we need to take care baby by our self for few days. Make us no choice and we had to changed the flight departure date for my mother in law early 1 week to come Singapore at next day to taking care of baby.

Nanny job scope in contract included wash of mummy and baby clothes. Clean baby room and kitchen after cooked. Although she did not do all these, and make a mess in our kitchen, but we are still ok with it. She even caused my baby umbilical cord infection with water during bathes. We were one eye open and one eye closed. More importantly she can taking care baby and mummy.

As what we understand that, Chris aunty had continuously taken the confinement job for 3 months Aug, Sep, Oct, Nov (us). Probably she had not taken a good rest and caused her sick after worked only 5 days in our house. We believe in Confinement Angels can find a same quality for 3 stars replacement nanny, so we want aunty Chris to get some rest. We want the healthy nanny to taking care baby and mummy.

2nd Nanny - Tham Yo** E** (52 years Old)

We thought Confinement Angels would arranged the same quality 3 stars replacement nanny. When replacement nanny arrived, after talking with her and we just realized that she just a part time nanny. She has not handle single case in Singapore. She even does not sign any contract agreement with Confinement Angels, just a freelance nanny. We cannot believe that they just arranged the newbies hoping no complaints.

She had nice personality, and saying that she had done confinement in Malaysia but not in Singapore. I feel that it a hassle to change another nanny and willing to give her a chance to try. Unfortunately, she cannot handle baby at night, overslept, snoring very loud and response a bit slow. She gave up after 2 days and herself informed nanny team to get a replacement for us.

3rd Nanny - LEE SA* W** (38 years old)

We have been informed that they cannot find any 3 stars nanny for us which made us super upset. This is also a very bad confinement period for my wife as well. All these plays a part in making us busy and my wife not being able to rest during confinement.

No choice, we had to accept it. We hope that standard nanny is still ok. Because Confinement Angels assure they provide high quality trained Malaysian Confinement Nannies based on Thomson Parentcraft Confinement Nanny Training Syllabus before we engage their services.

When 3rd nanny arrived, we communicated with nanny on the house rules, preferred style of taking care baby and routines to ensure nanny understand our requirements.

She say she have experience in Singapore but I feel that she is not up to standard in a certain way. Although she did everything what we have requested; but she taking baby skill is not very good compared to first nanny.

She cooking skill is also not good, confinement foods she cooked was not delicious. Every time when we asked her what to cook, she just response whatever ingredient available and then will cook accordingly. Kind of, we buy what and she cook what, no daily menu. She even cooked 1 veg and 1 egg dishes took 90 minutes.

After a week, we noticed that during midnight, she play with her phone watch video and weechat. Moreover, sometime carry a phone during daytime in pocket when cooking or in toilet. Then we warn her and requested her to put the phone in living room. She can only use the phone during her resting time. Own underwear and bra should use hand wash, surprisingly she using wash machine to wash her bra and told us that she do not know. But when she came, we already talked about the house rules. She is adult and should know this is a hygiene issue.

Her listening also got some problem, sometime cannot hear what we say and do not understand what we saying.

When she first came, we also told her after cooking, she need to check what ingredient not enough and need to let us know 1 day before, so we got time to buy. One day evening, when she going to cook dinner for my wife, then last minute told us that no more meat.

We were very unhappy with that. As she no need to clean baby room, wash of mummy and baby clothes, my mother in law has done all these housework. She just need to cook confinement food and general baby care, but she cannot even perform well the basic requirements. We are speechless and disappointed. She did not even let us check her luggage before leaving; in contract she should ask us to check her bags.

Thoroughly disappointed with Confinement Angels replacement nannies. Never expected so tiring and bad confinement period for my wife. 3 nannies, we gave 3 red packets for start a job and 1 appreciation red packet for 3rd nanny, although her performance not up to expectation.

1st Nanny, only worked 5 days falling sick. Before engage with them, they promised all their nanny doing medical check-up and healthy. Why arranged the nanny that had been continuously worked for 3 months, as nanny job is quite tiring. When our turn, it was nanny 4th assignment in the rows. Come to replacement, they could not find the same quality nanny.

2nd Nanny had never done confinement in Singapore. Never inform us that she is a part time, but we were paying for 3 stars nanny. They at least send a qualified nanny instead of newbies hoping no complaints.

3rd Nanny was also unprofessional, unqualified and inexperienced.

Confinement Angels emphasize they are the Accredited Partner of Thomson Parentcraft Centre which provide high quality trained Malaysian Confinement Nannies based on Thomson Parentcraft Confinement Nanny Training Syllabus. But the standard of replacement nannies were totally unprofessional, unqualified and inexperienced. We would rather not have confinement nanny than to engage one from Confinement Angels for my second child.

In the end, we would like to thanks for Linda and Vivian to assist us during these period. Just their nanny team did not do a great job.

No response received yet
Are you the Nanny involved in this case?
Your personal information will not be shared
Be the first to comment
Do you have a Complaint?
Submit your complaint for public viewing.